The Private Equity Pitch and Its Fine Print
If you’re a physician owner of a specialty practice with $5 million or more in revenue, you’ve received the call. Private equity firms are actively acquiring specialty practices across nearly every discipline, from ophthalmology to gastroenterology to orthopedics.
The pitch is appealing: a significant upfront payment, continued clinical leadership, operational support, and growth capital. What the pitch doesn’t emphasize is the equity rollover requirements, the debt loaded onto the practice, the aggressive timeline to the next transaction, and the gradual erosion of clinical autonomy.
PE-backed practices operate on a three-to-seven-year investment cycle. Every operational decision is filtered through the question of whether it increases the practice’s value at the next sale. That’s not inherently bad, but it’s not the same as running a practice for the long-term benefit of physicians and patients.
What Physicians Actually Want
When you strip away the financial engineering, most physician owners want four things: reduced administrative burden, growth capital for expansion, operational expertise they don’t have to build internally, and preservation of clinical independence.
Private equity delivers the first three but struggles with the fourth. The MSO model is designed to deliver all four because the MSO provides services to the practice rather than owning it. The physicians retain equity, governance, and clinical decision-making authority.
The MSO Growth Model
An MSO supports practice growth through operational infrastructure rather than financial leverage.
For geographic expansion, the MSO provides the operational backbone for new office locations: site selection analysis, lease negotiation, build-out project management, staffing, and payer enrollment. The practice opens new locations without diverting physician attention from patient care.
For service line expansion, the MSO handles the operational feasibility analysis, regulatory compliance, equipment procurement, and workflow design. A dermatology practice adding Mohs surgery or an orthopedic group adding an ambulatory surgery center benefits from MSO expertise without giving up equity.
For practice acquisitions, the MSO provides integration support: merging revenue cycles, standardizing operations, and aligning cultures. This is the area where MSO partnerships most directly compete with PE as a growth strategy.
Financial Comparison: PE vs. MSO
The financial structures differ fundamentally.
Private equity provides a large upfront payment, typically 8 to 12 times EBITDA, in exchange for majority ownership. The physician retains a minority equity stake and typically continues to work under an employment agreement for three to five years. The physician benefits again if the practice is sold at a higher multiple in the next transaction, but this outcome isn’t guaranteed.
An MSO charges fees for services, typically structured as a percentage of collections or a fixed monthly fee. The physician retains 100% ownership of the practice. There’s no upfront liquidity event, but the physician keeps all future earnings and the full value of the practice.
The right choice depends on the physician’s priorities. If immediate liquidity is the primary goal, PE delivers that. If long-term wealth accumulation and clinical independence are the priorities, the MSO model preserves both.
Questions to Ask Before Choosing
Physicians considering either path should ask several questions.
What happens to my clinical autonomy after year three? In a PE deal, the investment thesis may require changes to scheduling, referral patterns, or service mix that conflict with your clinical judgment. In an MSO arrangement, clinical decisions remain yours.
What is the total cost of capital? PE debt is loaded onto the practice’s balance sheet. If the next transaction doesn’t materialize at a higher multiple, the practice bears the debt. MSO fees are an operating expense with no balance sheet impact.
What does my practice look like in ten years? PE will likely sell your practice to another PE firm or a strategic acquirer. Under an MSO model, your practice remains independently owned by physicians.
Can I leave? PE employment agreements typically include restrictive covenants that limit your ability to practice within a geographic area if you depart. MSO service agreements don’t restrict your clinical practice.
The decision isn’t just financial. It’s about what kind of practice you want to run and who you want making the decisions.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Nexwell Health Partners provides management services, telehealth solutions, and compliance support for safety-net hospitals, FQHCs, and specialty practices. Contact us to schedule a consultation.
Sources